North Koreans in China gripped by repatriation fears as bilateral ties resume

North Koreans living in China without legal status are growing increasingly anxious as signs emerge of a broader thaw in relations between Pyongyang and Beijing, with many interpreting resumed transportation links as a signal that a systematic forced repatriation program could soon be restored.

The resumption of international rail service between Beijing and Pyongyang, followed by the restart of air travel between the two capitals, has rekindled hopes in some quarters of expanded people-to-people exchange. For North Koreans hiding in China, however, the same developments represent a direct threat to their survival.

A Daily NK source reported on April 7 that fear of forced repatriation is spreading rapidly within those communities. “Rumors that China-North Korea relations are improving have been circulating among North Koreans here, and anxiety and dread over being sent back are growing again,” the source said.

According to the source, expectations of a fuller diplomatic and economic restoration have been building across China, with speculation that the revival of bilateral ties could quickly expand to trade and material exchange. For North Koreans living there without legal status, that prospect carries a darker implication.

“What North Koreans here fear most is the possibility that forced repatriations will become routine again,” the source said. “There is real anxiety that what used to take months or even a year could now happen in less than a month.”

No way to escape forced repatriation

That fear is grounded in lived experience. Before the COVID-19 pandemic, North Koreans apprehended by Chinese public security forces were typically held for one to two weeks before being handed over to North Korean authorities. Families sometimes used that window to make contact with officials or gather funds to stall or prevent a repatriation. A faster process would eliminate that option entirely.

“If the detention period is short and repatriation moves quickly, there is essentially no way to escape it,” the source said.

One North Korean living in Jilin province, referred to here as A, described the discomfort of watching Chinese acquaintances grow excited about the prospect of visiting North Korea. “People around me keep saying they’d love to go now that it’s becoming possible,” A said. “Some even ask me why I can’t go too. It’s hard to explain.”

“Even if the door is open, I can’t walk through it,” A added. “When someone says that to me, it just makes everything heavier. What is good news for some people is the opposite for people like me.”

Another North Korean in China, referred to as B, said a fellow North Korean approached last month with a proposal to attempt the journey to South Korea together. “They told me, ‘We don’t know when we’ll be caught, so let’s go,'” B said. “But I was arrested once before, and I can’t easily make that decision again.”

B described being caught between two fears: the danger of attempting to reach South Korea and the dread of being repatriated if bilateral ties deepen further. “I keep thinking I could suddenly be sent back without warning,” B said. “These days I can’t eat properly or sleep.”

A survival issue, not a diplomatic one

For North Koreans without legal standing in China, the warming of ties between the two governments is not an abstraction. China does not recognize North Koreans who have crossed the border without authorization as refugees. Instead, it classifies them as illegal economic migrants subject to deportation under a bilateral agreement with Pyongyang. Human rights organizations, including Human Rights Watch, have documented how forced repatriations expose North Koreans to detention, torture, and imprisonment upon return.

The source noted that the vulnerability of this population grows in direct proportion to the strength of bilateral ties. “North Koreans in China are treated as illegal migrants, so as China-North Korea relations deepen, their personal safety comes under greater threat,” the source said. “I hope that conditions can be created where North Koreans trying to reach South Korea and those staying here can both live with less danger and less fear.”

Read in Korean

A Note to Readers